West Virginia Providers and Advocates File Lawsuit to Stop Cruel 19th Century Law Criminalizing Abortion
CHARLESTON, W.Va. ā Following the shameful decision by the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade ā the landmark decision that acknowledged the right to an abortion to millions of Americans for nearly five decades ā West Virginia medical providers and advocates have filed a lawsuit to prevent the enforcement of an archaic and cruel abortion ban in state court. Fear of prosecution under this outdated law has already forced the stateās only abortion clinic to suspend abortion services and turn away patients seeking essential care.
The Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ, Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ of West Virginia (Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ-WV), Mountain State Justice (MSJ), and the Cooley law firm filed the lawsuit in Kanawha County Circuit Court on Wednesday, June 29, 2022 on behalf of Womenās Health Center of West Virginia (WHC) and its staff.
The statute in question, enacted by the state legislature in the late 1800s, not only criminalized the provision of abortion care, but was also used to punish the person seeking the abortion (and even their partners).
The lawsuit argues the statute should be considered void under the doctrine of ārepeal by implication,ā a legal concept recognized in West Virginia courts that holds an older law is made void when a newer, conflicting law is passed. West Virginia lawmakers have passed law after law over the years regulating the provision of legal abortion, and many of them conflict with the provisions of the criminal abortion statute, Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ-WV Legal Director Loree Stark said.
āWe will not stand by while this state is dragged back to the 1800s,ā Stark said. āEvery day that uncertainty remains about the enforceability of this statute is another day that West Virginians are being denied critical, lifesaving healthcare. Thatās why we are asking the Court to make it clear this law cannot be enforced.ā
Alexa Kolbi-Molinas, deputy director of the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ Reproductive Freedom Project, said: āthe Supreme Court ruling was an unprecedented attack on reproductive freedom.ā
āNo one should be forced to carry a pregnancy against their will and face the life-altering consequences of being denied essential health care,ā Kolbi-Molinas said. āOur access to abortion shouldnāt depend on where we live, how much money we make, or who we are. We will continue to fight to protect our freedom to make our own decisions about our bodies and our futures in West Virginia and across the country.ā
Katie QuiƱonez, WHC executive director, said: āWith the overturning of Roe v. Wade, our worst nightmares have become reality. Because of the uncertainty over this state law, we have ceased providing abortion care to our patients out of concern for their safety, as well as the safety of our staff members.
āI worry deeply about our most vulnerable patients who are left with few and difficult options ā those who cannot make the expensive trip to travel out of state, will either be forced to continue their pregnancies against their will, or risk criminalization by self-managing their own abortion.ā
Sarah K. Brown, Mountain State Justice executive director, said the lawās impact on the health and wellbeing of West Virginians cannot be overstated.
āThe law in question has not been enforced for 50 years,ā Brown said. āThere should never be uncertainty between West Virginians and their medical providers.ā
Kathleen Hartnett, Cooley LLP, said: āWe look forward to demonstrating that this archaic law is null and void. Cooley is proud to work with the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ and Mountain State Justice on behalf of our clients at the Womenās Health Center of West Virginia to redress the irreparable harm this law is causing.ā
Reproductive Freedom
Womenās Health Center of West Virginia, et al. v. Charles Miller, et al.
Reproductive Freedom
Womenās Health Center of West Virginia, et al. v. Charles Miller, et al.
Learn More Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ the Issues in This Press Release
-
Press ReleaseJul 2025
Reproductive Freedom
Judge Issues Preliminary Injunctions Again Blocking Missouriās Abortion Bans, Some Restrictions. Explore Press Release.Judge Issues Preliminary Injunctions Again Blocking Missouriās Abortion Bans, Some Restrictions
Kansas City, Mo. ā A Jackson County circuit court judge issued a preliminary injunction blocking the enforcement of Missouriās abortion bans and several targeted regulations of abortion providers. The new preliminary injunction clears the way for Missouriās Planned Parenthood members to again provide procedural abortion care. In May, the Missouri Supreme Court clarified the stateās legal standard for issuing a preliminary injunction, forcing the circuit court to temporarily vacate its original orders, and effectively implement a de facto abortion ban. āWhile the clarification on the standard is welcome, its immediate consequence temporarily pulled back implementation of Missouriansā constitutional right to access abortion care and providersā right to offer that care,ā said Gillian Wilcox, Director of Litigation at the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ of Missouri. āThis critical win begins to restore abortion access in our state, but Missourians must be vigilant and defeat the attacks on the constitutional rights that we secured at the ballot box last November.ā āAbortion is legal again in Missouri because voters demanded it and we fought for it,ā said Emily Wales, president and CEO, Comprehensive Health of Planned Parenthood Great Plains. āCare starts again on Monday in Kansas City. Weāre not stopping until every Missourian can get the care they need, close to home.ā āWe are grateful that procedural abortion can resume in the state of Missouri, just as voters demanded last November. However, the whiplash has created immense confusion for patients in Missouri,ā said Margot Riphagen, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood Great Rivers. āThis decision is a step forward toward fully realizing Missourians' right to reproductive freedom, and the staff at our Central West End health center in St. Louis will work as quickly as possible to resume scheduling abortion appointments." The order did not address the pending request to enjoin other targeted restrictions that are preventing medication abortion access from being restored in Missouri. Previously, both Comprehensive Health of Planned Parenthood Great Plains and Planned Parenthood Great Rivers-Missouri submitted complication plans to satisfy the existing requirements to allow them to offer medication abortions. The Department of Health and Senior Services failed to respond to either affiliatesā submissions or follow-up inquiries for several weeks. Instead, the department manufactured an āemergency ruleā that resembled many of the court-blocked regulations and cited it as the reason for refusing the submitted plans. The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Comprehensive Health of Planned Parenthood Great Plains and Planned Parenthood Great Rivers-Missouri, who are represented by attorneys from the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ of Missouri, the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ, Crowell & Moring, and Planned Parenthood Federation of America. The full case is currently slated for trial in January 2026. -
Press ReleaseJul 2025
Disability Rights
+2 Issues
Aclu Statement On Final Passage Of Massive Budget Bill Cutting Medicaid To Fund Abusive Deportation Efforts. Explore Press Release.Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ Statement on Final Passage of Massive Budget Bill Cutting Medicaid to Fund Abusive Deportation Efforts
WASHINGTON ā The U.S. House of Representatives today gave final approval to H.R. 1, a budget bill that guts Medicaid and will wreak havoc on our communities, sending it to President Trumpās desk for his signature. H.R. 1 is the biggest cut to Medicaid in history ā slashing approximately $1 trillion, which will result in at least 12 million people being removed from the program. The bill also cuts off access to Planned Parenthood services for Medicaid enrollees and restricts higher education opportunities, all to fund a dramatic and permanent increase to an immigration detention and deportation apparatus that denies due process and violates human rights. Following the vote in the House, Deirdre Schifeling, chief political and advocacy officer with the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ, issued the following statement: āThis reckless monstrosity is the most harmful bill to pass Congress in a generation. Instead of strengthening Medicaid, theyāve taken an axe to it. Instead of reining in ICEās abuses, Congress is throwing the agency billions more to terrorize our communities. āWhen 12 million people are kicked off Medicaid, patients are no longer able to get lifesaving cancer screenings at Planned Parenthood, disabled people lose access to essential care and autonomy, and ICE ramps up lawless raids in our communities, the American people will remember who caused this devastation to our health, rights, and dignity. We wonāt let them forget.ā -
Press ReleaseJun 2025
Reproductive Freedom
Women's Rights
Aclu Responds To Supreme Court Greenlighting State Efforts To ādefundā Planned Parenthood. Explore Press Release.Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ Responds to Supreme Court Greenlighting State Efforts to āDefundā Planned Parenthood
WASHINGTON ā The Supreme Court ruled today that Medicaid patients do not have a right to sue to enforce their right to a qualified health care provider of choice under the Medicaid statute. The decision in Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic will facilitate some statesā politically motivated efforts to block low-income patientsā access to certain health care providers and may effectively defund Planned Parenthood and other disfavored providers by barring them from state Medicaid programs. āThe majority decision in Medina v. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic contradicts Congressās clear purpose to give Medicaid patients their choice of qualified health care providers and also wrongly curtails patientsā rights to vindicate their choice of provider through Section 1983,ā said Cecillia Wang, National Legal Director for the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ. āThe decision may have the effect of blocking patientsā access to birth control, cancer screenings, and STI testing and treatment for patients in South Carolina and potentially will permit state officials to override patientsā choice of provider based on political whims.ā āThe impact of this decision on our reproductive freedom will be compounded if Congress follows through on federal efforts to 'defund' Planned Parenthood by prohibiting patients from choosing Planned Parenthood health centers for their care,ā said Deirdre Schifeling, Chief Political and Advocacy Officer of the Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ. āDoing so would force the closure of hundreds of Planned Parenthood health centers nationwide, robbing people of their freedom to get reproductive health care from trusted providers in their communities and would result in shuttering 1 in 4 of the countryās abortion providers. "Make no mistake: our reproductive freedom is still under siege. The Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ remains committed to fighting for Planned Parenthood, abortion access, and the fundamental human right to control oneās own body using every tool we have. -
Press ReleaseJun 2025
Reproductive Freedom
Aclu Joins 100+ Abortion Storytellers On Capitol Hill In Advocating For Reproductive FreedomĀ . Explore Press Release.Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ Joins 100+ Abortion Storytellers on Capitol Hill in Advocating for Reproductive FreedomĀ
WASHINGTON ā The Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ joined more than 100 abortion storytellers on Capitol Hill today to demand that lawmakers defend the reproductive freedom of people across the country against escalating attacks in Congress and by the Trump administration. The education day, organized by Abortion Access Now (AAN) and Free & Just, brought the largest storyteller convening for abortion rights to the Hill since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade three years ago. Abortion patients, providers, and advocates held over 100 meetings with members of Congress on both sides of the aisle, speaking directly to lawmakers about the human toll of abortion bans: delayed medical care, severe health complications, and even the loss of womenās lives. As part of the education day on the Hill, Ķųŗģ±¬ĮĻ Chief Political and Advocacy Officer Deirdre Schifeling, shared the following remarks at an event with lawmakers. āThree years on from the Dobbs decision, reproductive freedom and our right to bodily autonomy are still under siege. The attacks are not coming in the most obvious or direct way, a national abortion ban passed by Congress, because they know the American people wonāt stand for it. Instead, itās a ādeath by many cutsā strategy designed by anti-abortion politicians to eliminate access nationwide, even in states where care is protected. āRight now, Congress is considering ādefundingā Planned Parenthood by blocking Medicaid patients from using their insurance there, which would shutter 1 in 4 of the countryās abortion providers. The FDA is using junk science to justify making medication abortion harder for patients to get even where it is legal. And the Trump administration continues to make reckless decisions that create chaos and confusion for patients seeking emergency care and their health care providers across the country. āOur communities need congressional leaders to hold the Trump administration accountable, and to act with the urgency that this moment requires to protect our reproductive freedom.ā